Citations to Conversations: Why GEO Isn't Enough
The real opportunity lies in being present inside AI platforms, not as a citation, but as an interactive experience.
Co-Founder & COO, Noodle Seed
The way people discover businesses is fundamentally changing. Over 800 million people now use ChatGPT weekly. Millions more use Claude, Perplexity, and Gemini as their first stop for product research, recommendations, and purchasing decisions.
This shift has given birth to an entirely new discipline: Generative Engine Optimization (GEO), the practice of optimizing your digital presence for AI platform citations.
But here's what most businesses don't realize: optimizing to be mentioned in AI responses is just the first level. The real opportunity lies in being present inside these platforms, not as a citation, but as an interactive experience.
Key Takeaways: GEO vs. AI Platform Presence
800+ million weekly ChatGPT users represent a massive shift in how consumers discover and purchase. AI platforms are becoming the new front door of the internet.
GEO has 70% citation volatility: roughly 70% of pages cited in AI responses change within 2-3 months, making visibility unpredictable and unsustainable.
Citations lose messaging control: AI platforms summarize and paraphrase your content, eliminating your carefully crafted value propositions and brand messaging.
App presence eliminates conversion friction: OpenAI's Apps SDK enables interactive experiences inside ChatGPT where users can browse, engage, and convert without leaving the conversation.
Early movers win: Target, Zillow, Spotify, and Booking.com already have app presence in ChatGPT. Businesses establishing presence now gain visibility, experience, and user base advantages.
TL;DR
- •GEO (Generative Engine Optimization) helps you get cited by AI platforms, but citations are inconsistent and you lose control of your messaging
- •Being mentioned isn't the same as being present. Users still have to leave the AI and navigate to your site
- •OpenAI's Apps SDK now lets businesses build interactive apps inside ChatGPT. Target, Zillow, and Spotify already have
- •App presence means controlling how you appear, enabling direct engagement, and eliminating conversion friction
- •The companies establishing AI platform presence now will define the next era of digital commerce
What is Generative Engine Optimization (GEO)?
Generative Engine Optimization (GEO) is the practice of structuring your content, brand presence, and digital footprint so that AI platforms like ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity, and Gemini cite, reference, or recommend you when users ask relevant questions.
Think of GEO as SEO's evolution for the AI era. Where traditional SEO helped you rank on Google's search results page, GEO optimization helps you appear inside ChatGPT's answers, Perplexity's AI-generated summaries, and Claude's recommendations. As generative AI platforms process billions of queries monthly, GEO has become critical for digital visibility.
The mechanics are straightforward: AI platforms synthesize information from across the web to generate responses. GEO strategies focus on making your content more "extractable" and authoritative so large language models (LLMs) are more likely to reference you in their AI-generated answers.
Common GEO Optimization Tactics Include:
- •Structured content: Creating clear headers, summaries, and extractable data that AI models can easily parse and cite
- •Authoritative backlinks: Building brand mentions across high-authority domains that LLMs trust
- •Schema markup implementation: Using JSON-LD and structured data to enhance AI comprehension
- •Query-focused content: Creating content that directly answers common questions in your industry
- •Cross-platform consistency: Ensuring your information is consistent across Wikipedia, review sites, and knowledge bases that AI models reference
The Problem with GEO: You're Still a Passenger
GEO is valuable. But it has a fundamental limitation that most agencies won't tell you about: you're optimizing to be mentioned, not to be present.
When a user asks ChatGPT for the best CRM for small businesses and your company gets cited, that's a win. But you had no control over how you were presented, what features were highlighted, or whether the user could take action. You're dependent on the AI's interpretation of your web content.
This creates three significant challenges:
The Attribution Problem
AI citations are inconsistent. Research shows that roughly 70% of pages cited in AI responses change within two to three months. Your visibility today doesn't guarantee visibility tomorrow.
The Context Problem
AI platforms summarize and paraphrase. Your carefully crafted messaging gets compressed into whatever the model decides is relevant to that specific query. You lose control of your narrative.
The Conversion Problem
Even when you're cited, users still need to leave the AI platform, find your website, and navigate your conversion funnel. Every step is friction. Every click is a potential dropout.
GEO optimizes for mentions. But mentions don't close deals.
The Next Level: App Presence on AI Platforms
OpenAI recently transformed ChatGPT from a chatbot into a platform. With the new Apps SDK, businesses can now build interactive applications that live inside ChatGPT, appearing in conversations at exactly the right moment.
This isn't about being cited. This is about being present.
When Target launched their ChatGPT app, users could ask for help planning a holiday movie night and immediately browse products, build a basket, and purchase, all without leaving the conversation. When Zillow integrated, users could explore listings on an interactive map while chatting about their home search criteria.
The implications are significant:
- •Instead of hoping the AI mentions you favorably, you control exactly how your business appears
- •Instead of users clicking through to your website, they interact with your brand inside the AI platform they're already using
- •Instead of losing context between the AI conversation and your site, the AI helps users engage with your actual product or service
This represents a fundamental shift from passive discovery to active presence.
How Noodle Seed Approaches This Differently
Most GEO agencies focus on content optimization and hope for the best. They'll help you restructure your blog posts, build backlinks, and implement schema markup. These are table stakes.
Noodle Seed takes a different approach. We don't just optimize your content for AI visibility. We build your actual presence on AI platforms.
We create ChatGPT apps that put your business directly inside conversations with hundreds of millions of users. When someone asks a question relevant to your business, they don't just hear about you. They interact with you.
Native AI Experiences
Your app responds to natural language, adapts to user context, and provides interactive interfaces users can engage with directly in their chat.
Contextual Discovery
ChatGPT surfaces your app at exactly the right moment based on what users are discussing.
Direct Conversion
Users can browse your offerings, get personalized recommendations, and take action without ever leaving the conversation.
The Difference in Practice
Consider a financial services company.
With traditional GEO: You optimize your website content hoping ChatGPT mentions you when someone asks about investment options. Maybe you get cited. Maybe you don't. Either way, the user has to leave ChatGPT, find your website, navigate to the right page, and figure out how to engage.
With AI app presence: When that same user discusses investment options, your app can surface directly in the conversation. They can explore your offerings, get personalized recommendations based on their stated goals, and initiate the next step, all within the natural flow of their AI conversation.
| Factor | Traditional GEO | AI Platform App Presence |
|---|---|---|
| Visibility Control | Dependent on AI interpretation; 70% citation volatility over 2-3 months | Full control over presentation, features, and messaging |
| User Reach | Inconsistent mentions across AI platforms | Direct access to 800+ million ChatGPT weekly users |
| Messaging Control | AI summarizes and paraphrases your content | You define exactly how your business appears |
| User Engagement | Passive mention; users must leave AI platform | Interactive experience within the conversation |
| Conversion Path | Multi-step: AI → website → navigation → conversion | Direct: browse, engage, convert in conversation |
| Context Preservation | Context lost when user leaves AI platform | AI maintains full conversation context during interaction |
| Implementation | Content optimization, backlinks, schema markup | App development using OpenAI Apps SDK or platforms like Noodle Seed |
| Results | Increased mentions, inconsistent traffic | Direct engagement, measurable conversions, reduced friction |
The difference isn't incremental. It's categorical.
Why This Matters Now
AI platforms are becoming the new front door of the internet. OpenAI's apps reach over 800 million weekly users. That's not a niche channel. That's where consumer attention is migrating.
The companies that establish app presence on these platforms now will have significant advantages: early mover visibility, refined user experiences, and established user bases before competitors enter.
GEO gets you mentioned. App presence gets you in the room.
Moving Forward: From GEO to AI Platform Presence
The question isn't whether to invest in AI visibility. That's already essential. The question is whether you'll settle for being cited through Generative Engine Optimization (GEO) or position your business for direct presence on AI platforms.
Noodle Seed builds that presence. We're not an agency optimizing your content and hoping AI platforms notice. We're a technology platform creating the infrastructure for your business to exist natively inside ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity, and other AI platforms where hundreds of millions of users are already conducting their product research and making purchasing decisions.
The shift from search engines to AI platforms is the largest change in digital discovery in twenty years. The businesses that understand the difference between being mentioned and being present will define the next era of digital commerce.
Conclusion: The Future is Presence, Not Citations
Generative Engine Optimization (GEO) represents an important first step in AI platform visibility. Optimizing your content for AI citations helps you appear in ChatGPT answers, Perplexity summaries, and Claude recommendations. But GEO's fundamental limitations (70% citation volatility, loss of messaging control, and multi-step conversion friction) mean it's not enough for businesses serious about AI-driven growth.
AI platform app presence solves these limitations by putting your business directly inside conversations with 800+ million weekly ChatGPT users. Using platforms like OpenAI's Apps SDK, businesses can create interactive experiences that provide controlled messaging, direct engagement, and zero-friction conversions, all within the natural flow of AI conversations.
Major brands like Target, Zillow, Spotify, and Booking.com have already established their presence in ChatGPT. Early movers gain significant advantages: visibility while competition is low, refined user experiences through early feedback, and established user bases before market saturation.
The era of passive optimization is ending. The future belongs to businesses that build active presence where their customers are already spending time: inside AI platforms. GEO gets you mentioned. App presence gets you in the room.
Co-Founder & COO, Noodle Seed
Ready to move from citations to conversations?
Noodle Seed helps businesses build native presence on AI platforms. Stop hoping to be mentioned. Start being present.